Current:Home > MarketsIf you don't love the 3D movie experience, you're not alone -MoneyMatrix
If you don't love the 3D movie experience, you're not alone
View
Date:2025-04-12 19:41:00
I saw the Pixar film Elemental this week. It's a story about Element City, where fire people, water people, cloud/air people and earth people all live alongside each other, sometimes uncomfortably. Some things about it work better than others, but it's impossible, I think, not to admire the inventive way it creates its world of flames and bubbles and flowers and puffy clouds, and the way all those things make up the characters it's about. On top of that, those characters live in a world of smoke, rivers, and all kinds of other — shall we say — earthly delights.
The screening I attended was in 3D. I tend to have mixed feelings about 3D, which can certainly have its impressive "ooh, neat" moments, but which I tend to find more a gimmick than a genuine advantage — despite the fact that these days, it works pretty well. Even as a person who wears glasses and is therefore not perfectly suited to putting 3D glasses over them, I had no trouble with the 3D presentation itself as far as appreciating and enjoying the different layers of visuals.
The problem is that, as you know if you've ever picked up a pair of the RealD glasses that you use for a film like this, it considerably darkens the picture simply because of the 3D technology. You can see it — they are literally dark glasses, and as sunglasses would do, they make the picture look, you know, darker.
Particularly with something like a Pixar movie for kids, and extra-particularly for one that's so dependent on a lively presentation of nature, it's impossible for me to believe I even saw the best version of Elemental. I feel certain that my appreciation of its colorful take on the world would have been, what, 30% greater?, if I had just watched it in a regular 2D presentation.
I've always been a bit of a 3D skeptic — the glasses are fiddly and just become more plastic junk, the gimmicks wear off, it gets distracting, and it introduces more opportunities for technical problems (there were some at my screening). And for a while, I felt like my side was winning the argument — you don't see as many random "but this time it's 3D!" sequels as you did for a while, what with Saw 3D and Piranha 3D and Step Up 3D and so forth.
But one of the places 3D seems to persist is in animated kids' movies, which is the last place it belongs. Why would you want to watch an explosively colorful world unfold while wearing sunglasses? The people who create Pixar films are perfectly able to make those worlds immersive and unforgettable without exploiting a technology that degrades the experience on one level in order to supposedly improve it on another.
Honestly, maybe this is tech that belongs in cheapie horror sequels, where it can be used for jump scares and tricks in a genre that relies on them, rather than in films that are designed to be visually joyful.
Besides, who wants to try to make a squirming kid wear plastic glasses for two hours?
This piece also appeared in NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour newsletter. Sign up for the newsletter so you don't miss the next one, plus get weekly recommendations about what's making us happy.
Listen to Pop Culture Happy Hour on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
veryGood! (19969)
Related
- EU countries double down on a halt to Syrian asylum claims but will not yet send people back
- When does 2024 British Open start? How to watch golf's final major of season
- Steven Stamkos on move: 'I never thought this day would come'
- Messi’s Copa America injury adds doubt for rest of 2024, 2026 World Cup
- Intellectuals vs. The Internet
- Mass dolphin stranding off Cape Cod officially named the largest in U.S. history
- When does EA Sports College Football 25 come out? Some will get to play on Monday.
- A law passed last year made assault in an emergency room a felony. Did it help curb violence?
- South Korean president's party divided over defiant martial law speech
- Rep. Jason Crow says unless there is a major change, there's a high risk that Democrats lose the election
Ranking
- 2025 'Doomsday Clock': This is how close we are to self
- Mechanical issues prompt 2 Delta Air Lines flights to divert, return to airport
- Second day of jury deliberations to start in Sen. Bob Menendez’s bribery trial
- Old Navy’s 50% off Cyber Sale Is Here! Score Cute Summer Tops, Dresses & More Starting at $9.99
- Friday the 13th luck? 13 past Mega Millions jackpot wins in December. See top 10 lottery prizes
- How much money U.S., other countries are paying Olympic medalists at Paris Games
- Fresno State football coach Jeff Tedford steps down due to health concerns
- Schools receive third — and potentially final — round of federal funding for homeless students
Recommendation
FACT FOCUS: Inspector general’s Jan. 6 report misrepresented as proof of FBI setup
2024 Home Run Derby: Time, how to watch, participants and more
RNC Day 1: Here's what to expect as the RNC kicks off in Milwaukee after Trump assassination attempt
What to watch as the Republican National Convention kicks off days after Trump assassination attempt
From family road trips to travel woes: Americans are navigating skyrocketing holiday costs
Texas governor criticizes Houston energy as utility says power will be restored by Wednesday
Social media influencers tell you to buy, buy, buy. Stop listening to them.
Social media influencers tell you to buy, buy, buy. Stop listening to them.